CareerPaths homeCareerPaths home
Career Visibility Healthcheck

Career conversations with employees: the appraisal is the wrong meeting

Nobody explores an honest ambition in the meeting that decides their rating. Which is why most career conversations produce nothing.
by Carolyn Saddington
09 September 2026
3 min read
Share

Nobody explores an honest ambition in the meeting that decides their rating. Which is why most career conversations produce nothing.

Most organisations have career conversations. They are item six on the appraisal form, after objectives, performance, behaviours, rating and development needs.

By the time anybody reaches item six there are four minutes left, and both people know what the meeting was really about.

What actually happens in those four minutes

The manager asks where the employee sees themselves in five years. The employee says they are happy where they are and would like to keep developing.

Both answers are safe. Neither is true often enough to be useful.

The employee has just been rated. Saying "I would like your job" or "I am not sure this is the right path" in that meeting carries a cost, and people are good at arithmetic.

The problem is the meeting, not the manager

A performance review decides money and standing. A career conversation needs somebody to say something uncertain out loud.

Those two purposes cannot share an hour. The first will always win, because it has consequences attached and the second does not.

So the fix is not better questions on the appraisal form. It is a separate meeting, at a different time of year, with no rating attached and nothing to sign.

The sentence that changes it

"Nothing we discuss here affects your rating or your pay. This is a different conversation."

Say it at the start, and mean it. If a manager later uses something from that meeting in a performance discussion, the whole thing is finished across the team within a month, because people talk.

Better questions than "where do you see yourself in five years"

That question asks somebody to commit publicly to an ambition they may not have formed. These ask for information instead.

"Which part of your current role would you keep if you could drop the rest?"

"Is there anyone here whose job you would want in a few years?" Specific, and far easier to answer than an abstraction.

"What would you need to be able to do that you cannot do now?" This is the question that produces a development plan worth having.

"What would make you look outside?" Uncomfortable, and the most valuable answer in the meeting.

What managers are actually avoiding

Most managers avoid career conversations because they are afraid of two things.

That somebody will ask for a promotion they cannot give. And that they will be asked a question about the organisation's structure they cannot answer.

The first is manageable. "I cannot promise that, and here is what would have to be true" is a perfectly good answer.

The second is not a management problem at all. If a manager cannot say what routes exist from a role, that is because nobody has written them down. No amount of training fixes a missing map.

What to record, and what not to

Record the development actions, the dates and who owns them.

Do not record ambitions in a system the employee cannot see, and never in one their next manager will read before meeting them. A career conversation that quietly becomes a file is a career conversation that stops happening.

What good looks like

A separate meeting, twice a year, thirty minutes, no form to sign.

A manager who can answer "what could this role lead to" without hedging, because the routes are written down somewhere both of them can look.

And an employee who says something slightly risky, because the meeting was built so they could.

---

The Career Conversations Template Pack has the 45-minute agenda, a bank of 25 questions grouped by what they're for, preparation sheets for both sides, and language for the three hardest moments — including "I want your job". Free, and usable this week without changing anything else.*

In CareerPaths, Career Conversations gives managers the role and pathway information inside the meeting itself, so the question they couldn't answer stops being the reason the meeting goes badly.*

Related articles
chevron-down