Job advert or job description? Most vacancy pages are the wrong document
A job description is written to grade a role. An advert is written to make somebody want it. Most vacancy pages are the first, lightly edited, and it shows.
Open any vacancy page and read it as though you were deciding whether to apply.
You will usually find a purpose statement, a list of responsibilities, essential and desirable criteria, and a note about the grading. At the bottom there is a form.
That is a job description. It was written for evaluation, grading and consistency, by people who needed it to be defensible. It is a good document and it does its job well. It was never an advert, and it cannot work as one.
Where the words actually come from
A job description exists to answer internal questions. What band is this. How does it compare with the role next to it. Can we justify the salary.
An advert answers a different question entirely, which is whether somebody should want this job.
Nobody decides to change careers because a role was defensibly graded. But because the description already exists and is already approved, it becomes the advert, with a sentence of introduction and the salary moved to the top.
The test
Delete your organisation's name from your vacancy page and read it again.
If it could belong to any employer in your sector, it is a job description. The things that make a job yours are the things a description is designed to strip out: who you would work with, what the first six months look like, what the person before you went on to do.
We have run this on a lot of careers sites, including our clients' before we rebuilt them. Most pages fail it.
Why a redesign will not fix it
This is where careers website projects usually go wrong, and we spent years making the same mistake.
A redesign changes the template the words sit in. It does not change where the words come from. Six weeks after launch, somebody copies the next approved job description into the new design, and the page looks better while saying the same unreadable thing.
The fix is not visual. It is deciding that your vacancy page is a different document from your job description, and that it is built from role information written for the person reading it rather than for the panel grading it.
What changes when you do
A vacancy stops being a dead end.
Someone reading an advert for a role two levels below where they would like to be can see where that role leads, what the person in it is working towards, and what they would need to develop to get there. Same vacancy, completely different conversation.
That is not a copywriting exercise. It needs your roles to exist somewhere other than in forty separate pages, which is a structural question rather than a design one.
What this will not do
It will not fill a role nobody wants at a salary nobody accepts. An honest advert for a difficult job is still an advert for a difficult job.
What it changes is the people who were qualified, interested and quietly put off by a page that read like a grading exercise. You never hear from them, so you never know how many there were.
Eighteen months from now
The job descriptions will have been updated, because they have to be, because somebody is paid to keep them defensible.
The vacancy pages will not have been, because nobody owns them in the same way.
That gap is the whole problem, and it is why we stopped treating careers sites as a set of pages and started building them from the roles underneath.
---
The Careers Website Audit Checklist walks your site in candidate order — eight stops, about thirty minutes, with your site open in one tab. It produces a written list of specific findings you can hand to whoever owns the site. Free, no sales call.*
In CareerPaths, one place holds your roles, your framework and your jobs — and we build your careers site from it, so a role page carries what the role involves and where it leads, rather than starting again from a document written to grade it.
